An interdisciplinary struggle (who's licensed to
diagnose what); Integrative assessment; RTI model; The place and status of the
educational psychologist at school – Current
?issues
Not necessarily!
These are the issues Alfred Binet
(1857-1911) dealt with, according to this interesting paper:
Nicolas, S., Andrieu, B., Croizet, J.C., Sanitioso, R. B. and
Burman, J.T. Sick? Or slow? On the origins of intelligence as a psychological
object. Intelligence, Volume 41, Issue 5, September–October 2013, Pages
699–71. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160289613001232
What's in this paper :
In 1882 a law on compulsory
public education for children aged 6-14 was passed in France, after which teachers
began to complain about the presence of "slow" children in their
classrooms.
Binet joined a committee that
was tasked with studying the physical and mental differences between
"normal" and "abnormal" children. Psychiatrists were also among the members of
this committee.
A struggle
about the license to diagnose:
The psychiatrists wanted to
have the authority to determine who is an "abnormal" child and to
transfer him to special education classes inside psychiatric hospitals.
Binet thought these children
are not "sick" or "abnormal" but rather
"slow/behind" in their intelligence, and he collaborated with
educators to open special education classes in "normal" schools or in special, non psychiatric, establishments created for that purpose.
In 1908 Binet and Simon made
their first efforts to produce an intelligence test for children aged 3-13.
Here are some sample items:
Eye track a burning match
Repeat 8 fifteen word sentences
Answer questions: Suppose
someone hurt you and apologizes – what should you do? Suppose someone asks your
opinion about something you know little about – what should you do?
Define abstract concepts
(what's the difference between boredom and fatigue)
General knowledge questions and
questions about things learned at school.
The
need for an assessment before making a decision about the child's placement:
The committee decided that
children judged as being resistant to education, teaching or discipline will
not be expelled without first being submitted to an examination. If identified as "abnormal but
treatable", they will be grouped in a special class attached to the school
or in a special non medical establishment.
Integrative
assessment:
Following the creation of the
test, Binet and Simon suggested the children suspected for
"abnormality" be examined using
three different approaches: medical, pedagogical (crystallized/ acquired
knowledge) and psychological (intelligence).
An RTI
approach:
In 1908, Binet recommended
using his test only after first using pedagogical methods and only in cases
where a three year mental retardation was observed. Thus the test was used only after teachers
had indicated a need.
Creation
of the educational psychologist role:
Binet thus legitimized the role
of the psychologists in schools while limiting the role of psychiatrists and their
power to remove students from school.
Thank you so ably discussing our article. You hit all of the really major points that I think contemporary psychologists need to know about the origins of intelligence testing. None of what we discussed in the article is reflected in textbooks. It's blogs like yours that will help to change that, as ideas are disseminated and come to be more widely understood.
ReplyDelete